Question about which staff is best for an ice strike monk

Physical Damage Increased by 97%
Elemental Damage Increased by 98%
14% Critical Damage Compensation
11% Block Chance
+86 Accuracy
Attribute Requirements Reduced by 25%
4 Mana for Each Enemy Killed
—————————————
Physical Damage Increased by 161%
Adds 29 to 47 Physical Damage
+2 to Level of All Melee Skills
+141 Accuracy
+10 Intelligence
Stunning Duration Increased by 15%

Honestly, if it's between those 2... Neither one.

Gamble some gold with alva, you'll get something better than both of those in 3 tries, no joke.