**Trading Sucks in PoE2 – It’s Time for an In‑Game Auction House**

Hey folks, here’s why the current trade system is broken — and why we desperately need an Auction House.

---

## 🔴 What’s wrong with trading now

### 1. **Whisper spam & ghost listings**
- Players grind hours sending **hundreds of whispers**—sometimes 150–200 to buy a single item—with only a handful of responses.
- Many listings **persist after being sold**, leaving buyers ghosted long after making an offer.

### 2. **No buyer/seller commitment**
- Sellers frequently **relist items**, **raise prices mid-chat**, or **cancel offers entirely**.
- No reputation system or penalties exist for **no-shows** or **scam attempts**.

### 3. **Archaic, clunky process**
- You have to:
1. Open a browser
2. Search listings
3. Whisper the seller
4. Wait for a reply
5. Join their hideout
6. Trade manually
7. Hope they don’t cancel last-minute

…all just to buy a single item.

- Console and cross‑play users have it **even worse** without browser support or fast typing.

### 4. **Bot abuse & price manipulation**
- Bots **flood the market** at weird prices (e.g., 1 exalt each), then **snipe listings** and resell.
- **Dump tabs** with poorly priced items **clutter searches** and confuse players.

---

## 💡 Why an Auction House solves this

| **Benefit** | **Result** |
|-------------|------------|
| **Instant buyout** | No spam, no hideout invites, no wasted time |
| **In-game integration** | Trade without leaving the client |
| **Price transparency** | Real-time pricing history and filtering |
| **Auto transaction** | Safe, server-side currency and item handling |
| **Reputation system** | Trustworthy sellers rewarded, bad actors exposed |

A seamless internal system would eliminate the pain: **no spam**, **no scams**, **no ghost listings**.

---

## ⭐ Community voices

> *“It’s toxic, clunky, easy to exploit, and not fun to use.”*
> — Steam user

> *“Why tf do I have to log into some website … join their party … trade? … Removes me from the action.”*
> — Reddit user

> *“You dump stuff in… then you can’t be bothered to leave a map… Trade in this game is not good.”*
> — General sentiment on forums

---

## 📌 Call to GGG

We get it—**you want trade friction** to make items feel valuable.

But what we have now isn’t friction. It’s *punishment*.

- Players are driven to **external tools**, **Discord bots**, and **third-party websites** just to engage in basic trade.
- Early Access is the perfect time to test and evolve this. An Auction House **won’t ruin the game**—it’ll save the economy from bots, scams, and player burnout.

Add:
- Instant-buy options
- In-game trading UI
- Seller ratings or filters
- Server-side enforcement

Let us trade without stepping out of the game world.

---

**TL;DR:**
The current trading system is outdated, broken, and frustrating.
PoE2 deserves a modern solution.
**Add an in‑game Auction House.**

---

Let me know your thoughts — and if you agree, make some noise! 💥

+1!

agree +1

Of course +1, the game definitely needs an auction house or some form of offline trading, the current system is utter dog shit.

+1

+1

Trading is one of the weakest aspects of this game. Which is sad, because it is not so hard to implement. POE2 deserves better.

+1!! Trading is currently so slow and clunky. Added friction is just a turn off tbh

+1

+1

its not just that trading sucks. the entire loot system is absolute garbage.